Compare Amusement Parks
- 4,191
- 8
- All Reviews
- Customize
- All Rankings
Hersheypark vs Martin's Fantasy Island
Hersheypark is...
- Top Three for those who wantBest Amusement Parks
- Top Three out of the 120Amusement Parks for Families
- Top Three out of the 120Family Amusement Parks
- Top Three out of the 119Amusement Parks With Kiddie Coasters
- Top Three out of the 119Amusement Parks With Kiddie Rides
- Top Two out of the 74Thrill Seeker Amusement Parks
- Top Four forAmusement Parks for Roller Coaster Lovers
- Top Three out of the 107One-time Admission Fee Amusement Parks
- Top Three out of the 95Amusement Parks With Thrill Coasters
- Top Three out of the 95Amusement Parks With Thrill Rides
Hersheypark Description
Hersheypark is an expensive amusement park that features kiddie rides, live shows, thrill coasters and water park attractions, but doesn't have carnival-style games. It charges a very low fee for parking and offers a moderately priced season pass. It has an one-time admission fee policy. If you go to Hersheypark, check out their signature ride: The Coal Cracker.
#3 in Best Amusement Parks
Pros: Martin's Fantasy Island is...
- The Best if you wantWith Slow Roller Coaster Amusement Parks
- Top Three for those who wantAmusement Parks for Your Budget
- Top Five out of the 48Theme-based Amusement Parks
- Top Fifth out of the 120Amusement Parks for Families
- Top Four out of the 36Amusement Parks With Adult Admission Under $25
- Top Fifth out of the 120Family Amusement Parks
- Top Fifth for those who wantBest Amusement Parks
- Top Fifth out of the 119Amusement Parks With Kiddie Rides
- Top Fifth out of the 119Amusement Parks With Kiddie Coasters
- Top Fifth out of the 95Amusement Parks With Thrill Coasters
Cons: Martin's Fantasy Island is...
- Bottom Fifth if you care aboutAmusement Parks for Cheap Season Passes
Martin's Fantasy Island Description
Martin's Fantasy Island is an inexpensive amusement park that has kiddie rides and thrill coasters, but doesn't have live shows, carnival-style games or water park attractions. It charges a very low fee for parking and it has an one-time admission fee policy. If you go to Martin's Fantasy Island, check out their signature ride: The Beanstalk.
#17 in Best Amusement Parks
Hersheypark is ranked highest among the best amusement parks out of those selected. Based on input from our users, the most important dimensions of evaluation to consider if you're looking for the best amusement parks are, in order of importance: (1) cost, (2) rides and roller coasters, (3) games and entertainment and (4) park type. (It should be mentioned that park quality and park information are also important in choosing the best amusement parks, but they aren't the kind of factors on which amusement parks can be directly compared.) In addition to being the overall winner, Hersheypark is also the best in this group for rides and roller coasters, games and entertainment and park type. However, Martin's Fantasy Island scores best in cost. (more)
| 2021 | 2077 |
|---|
Most Important Facts for Best Amusement Parks:
Top Fact Comparison
| Mark Better Values | Hersheypark | Martin's Fantasy Island | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adult Admission |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for adult admission, Hersheypark achieves 35% performance in this category. $53.95 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for adult admission, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 87% performance in this category. $11.75 (wrong info?) |
|
|
Enjoyment Rating
Enjoyment Rating
How much fun was this amusement park? Would you recommend it to someone else?
|
|
|
|
| Parking Cost |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for parking cost, Hersheypark achieves 87% performance in this category. $12 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for parking cost, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 100% performance in this category. $0 (wrong info?) |
|
| Junior Admission |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for junior admission, Hersheypark achieves 55% performance in this category. $32.95 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for junior admission, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 73% performance in this category. $19.95 (wrong info?) |
|
| Season Pass Rate |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for season pass rate, Hersheypark achieves 81% performance in this category. $120 (wrong info?) |
We currently have no data on Martin's Fantasy Island for season pass rate. (wrong info?) |
|
|
Performs Best In
Performs Best In:
Who are these Amusement Parks best for?
These facts tell you where they score the highest and who they
are likely to perform best for.
|
Comparing Hersheypark to Martin's Fantasy Island: Which is the best amusement park?
Cost
Martin's Fantasy Island scores best for cost between these two amusement parks. Here's how it does on some key aspects of cost:
- Both of these amusement parks, including Martin's Fantasy Island, have a one-time admission fee.
- It costs $19.95 for kids. Compare Hersheypark at $32.95.
- It costs $0 to park. Compare Hersheypark at $12.
- It costs $11.75 for adults. Compare Hersheypark at $53.95.
| Mark Better Values | Hersheypark | Martin's Fantasy Island | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Admission Type |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have selected one-time admission fee as the top choice for admission type, Hersheypark achieves 100% performance in this category. One-time admission fee (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have selected one-time admission fee as the top choice for admission type, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 100% performance in this category. One-time admission fee (wrong info?) |
|
| Adult Admission |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for adult admission, Hersheypark achieves 35% performance in this category. $53.95 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for adult admission, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 87% performance in this category. $11.75 (wrong info?) |
|
| Season Pass Rate |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for season pass rate, Hersheypark achieves 81% performance in this category. $120 (wrong info?) |
We currently have no data on Martin's Fantasy Island for season pass rate. (wrong info?) |
|
| Junior Admission |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for junior admission, Hersheypark achieves 55% performance in this category. $32.95 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for junior admission, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 73% performance in this category. $19.95 (wrong info?) |
|
| Parking Cost |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for parking cost, Hersheypark achieves 87% performance in this category. $12 (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer lower values for parking cost, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 100% performance in this category. $0 (wrong info?) |
Rides And Roller Coasters
Hersheypark scores best for rides and roller coasters between these two amusement parks. Here's how it does on some key aspects of rides and roller coasters:
- Both of these amusement parks, including Hersheypark, have kiddie coasters.
- It has standard coasters. Compare Martin's Fantasy Island, which doesn't have standard coasters.
- Both of these amusement parks have thrill coasters.
- It has a huge drop of 180 feet. Compare Martin's Fantasy Island at 42 feet.
- It has a roller coaster that goes up to 75 mph. Compare Martin's Fantasy Island at 29 mph.
| Mark Better Values | Hersheypark | Martin's Fantasy Island | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Signature Ride
Signature Ride
A signature ride is typically what the park is most noted for. It may come in the form of a coaster, a water ride, or another form of thrill ride.
|
Storm Runner, Lightning Racer, Kissing Tower, Comet roller coaster (wrong info?) |
Beanstalk (wrong info?) |
|
| Signature Ride Description |
A hydroflume boat ride that gives guests a wet ride full of splashes through water canals, ending with one big plunge! **Hersheypark suggests that that if you plan on riding rides to please bring into the park only items that can be safely secured in cargo (wrong info?) |
Requirement (wrong info?) |
|
| Roller Coaster Types |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for thrill coasters, standard coasters and kiddie coasters and prefer a larger number of roller coaster types options, Hersheypark achieves 100% performance in this category. Kiddie coasters, standard coasters, thrill coasters (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for thrill coasters, standard coasters and kiddie coasters and prefer a larger number of roller coaster types options, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 29% performance in this category. Kiddie coasters, thrill coasters (wrong info?) |
|
| Ride Types |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for thrill rides, kiddie rides and transportation rides and prefer a larger number of ride types options, Hersheypark achieves 100% performance in this category. Kiddie rides, thrill rides, transportation rides (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for thrill rides, kiddie rides and transportation rides and prefer a larger number of ride types options, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 12% performance in this category. Kiddie rides, thrill rides, transportation rides (wrong info?) |
|
| Roller Coaster Quality | |||
| Number of Roller Coasters |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer higher values for number of roller coasters, Hersheypark achieves 68% performance in this category. 11 roller coasters (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer higher values for number of roller coasters, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 12% performance in this category. 2 roller coasters (wrong info?) |
|
| Fastest Speed |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer higher values for fastest speed, Hersheypark achieves 50% performance in this category. 75 mph (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer higher values for fastest speed, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 0% performance in this category. 29 mph (wrong info?) |
|
| Highest Drop |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer higher values for highest drop, Hersheypark achieves 37% performance in this category. 180 feet (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks prefer higher values for highest drop, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 1% performance in this category. 42 feet (wrong info?) |
|
|
Roller Coaster Rating
Roller Coaster Rating
How popular are the roller coasters in the park? Does the park offer a variety of roller coasters?
|
|
|
|
Park Quality
| Mark Better Values | Hersheypark | Martin's Fantasy Island | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Enjoyment Rating
Enjoyment Rating
How much fun was this amusement park? Would you recommend it to someone else?
|
|
|
|
|
Family-friendliness Rating
Family-friendliness Rating
Does the park offer rides for the whole family? Is there entertainment for both children and adults? Is the park a smoking, non-smoking, or partially smoke free environment?
|
|
|
|
|
Park Cleanliness Rating
Park Cleanliness Rating
Is the park litter free? Are trash receptacles conveniently placed throughout the park? How clean are the restrooms?
|
|
|
|
|
Fun Factor Rating
Fun Factor Rating
How fun is the park? Is there a lot to do at the park?
|
|
|
|
|
Low Crowd Rating
Low Crowd Rating
Is it easy to move around the park freely? Are the lines for refreshments typically low?
|
|
|
|
|
Short Lines Rating
Short Lines Rating
Are the lines for rides short? Is the wait time for rides reasonable?
|
|
|
Games And Entertainment
Hersheypark scores best for games and entertainment between these two amusement parks. Most amusement parks are equipped with more than just rides. Many offer live entertainment, games, and even tours. Here's how Hersheypark does on some key aspects of games and entertainment:
- It has themed areas. Compare Martin's Fantasy Island, which doesn't have themed areas.
- It has live shows. Compare Martin's Fantasy Island, which doesn't have live shows.
| Mark Better Values | Hersheypark | Martin's Fantasy Island | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Games and Entertainment
Games and Entertainment
Most amusement parks are equipped with more than just rides. Many offer live entertainment, games, and even tours.
|
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for carnival-style games, themed areas and live shows and prefer a larger number of games and entertainment options, Hersheypark achieves 52% performance in this category. Themed areas, live shows (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for carnival-style games, themed areas and live shows and prefer a larger number of games and entertainment options, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 0% performance in this category. No special games and entertainment details (wrong info?) |
Park Type
Hersheypark scores best for park type between these two amusement parks. Here's how it does on some key aspects of park type:
- It is a carnival-style park. Compare Martin's Fantasy Island, which isn't a carnival-style park.
- It has water attractions. Compare Martin's Fantasy Island, which doesn't have water attractions.
- Both of these amusement parks are recommended for thrill seekers.
- Both of these amusement parks are family oriented.
| Mark Better Values | Hersheypark | Martin's Fantasy Island | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Park Type |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for family, water and carnival-style and prefer a larger number of park type options, Hersheypark achieves 94% performance in this category. Family, thrill seeker, carnival-style, water (wrong info?) |
Given that users looking for the best overall amusement parks have a preference for family, water and carnival-style and prefer a larger number of park type options, Martin's Fantasy Island achieves 67% performance in this category. Family, theme-based, thrill seeker (wrong info?) |
Park Information
| Mark Better Values | Hersheypark | Martin's Fantasy Island | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Address |
Hershey, Pennsylvania (wrong info?) |
Grand Island, New York (wrong info?) |
|
| Zip Code |
17033 (wrong info?) |
14072 (wrong info?) |
|
| Park Telephone |
(770) 948-9290 (wrong info?) |
18663862 (wrong info?) |
|
| Guest Services |
First Aid, Lost and Found, Lost Child Service, Park Maps (wrong info?) |
(wrong info?) |
|
| Website |
Website (wrong info?) |
Website (wrong info?) |
|
| Hotels and Lodging Options |
The Hotel Hershey, Hershey Highmeadow Campground, Hershey Lodge. (wrong info?) |
(wrong info?) |
|
| Food Vendors and Restaurants |
(wrong info?) |
(wrong info?) |
|
| Months of Operation |
Spring to late Fall (wrong info?) |
Spring to late Fall (wrong info?) |
|
| Hours of Operation |
12p.m. to 10p.m. (wrong info?) |
11a.m. to 7:30p.m. (wrong info?) |
|
| Park Email Address |
info@hersheypa.com (wrong info?) |
info@martinsfantasyisland.com (wrong info?) |
Comparing Hersheypark to Martin's Fantasy Island
If you're trying to decide among amusement parks, you may be considering both Hersheypark and Martin's Fantasy Island. Based on input from thousands of users, we've learned that cost, rides and roller coasters and park quality are the most important considerations for choosing between amusement parks. When we compared these two amusement parks, we found that Hersheypark scores better in rides and roller coasters. On the other hand, Martin's Fantasy Island prevails for cost. These amusement parks are radically different from one another, and which is best for you ultimately depends on who you are and what you value in amusement parks.
Cost: if you're searching for amusement parks for families, it's a crucial consideration.
Cost is often rated as the most important factor in choosing amusement parks for families, in addition to amusement parks for your budget and amusement parks for cheap season passes. Cost is made up of five sub-categories: adult admission, season pass rate, junior admission, parking cost and admission type.
For cost, an important difference between Hersheypark and Martin's Fantasy Island is adult admission. While the adult admission for Hersheypark is $53.95, that of Martin's Fantasy Island is $11.75, a sizable difference of $42.20. Adult admission is especially important to amusement parks for your budget.
Rides and Roller Coasters should be on your radar if you're looking for amusement parks for roller coaster lovers.
Rides and roller coasters is often rated as the most important factor in choosing amusement parks for roller coaster lovers. Rides and roller coasters is made up of five sub-categories: signature ride, signature ride description, roller coaster quality, roller coaster types and ride types.
One factor that goes into evaluating rides and roller coasters is thrill rides, which is important for ranking amusement parks for roller coaster lovers. Many people find that thrill rides is a significant consideration, and both Hersheypark and Martin's Fantasy Island feature thrill rides.
For roller coaster quality, an important difference between Hersheypark and Martin's Fantasy Island is number of roller coasters. While the number of roller coasters for Hersheypark is 11 roller coasters, that of Martin's Fantasy Island is 2 roller coasters, a sizable difference of 9 roller coasters. Number of roller coasters is especially important to amusement parks for roller coaster lovers.
Park Quality: keep it in mind if you want amusement parks for water park lovers.
Park quality is often rated as the most important factor in choosing amusement parks for water park lovers. Park quality is made up of six sub-categories: enjoyment rating, family-friendliness rating, park cleanliness rating, fun factor rating and others.
One factor that goes into evaluating park quality is enjoyment rating, which is important for ranking amusement parks for water park lovers. Many people find that enjoyment rating is a significant consideration, and the difference between Hersheypark at 4 stars stars and Martin's Fantasy Island at unknown stars is currently not known.
Overall...
When we compared Hersheypark to Martin's Fantasy Island, we calculated both of their PikiRanks. PikiRank measures each item's performance for all users combined. Hersheypark is ranked 3rd out of 145 while Martin's Fantasy Island is ranked 17th, meaning that given our users' preferences, Hersheypark is superior overall. To give your input, share your preferences, and compare more items, visit our Piki for amusement parks!
Hersheypark Price Comparison
| Sale | Price | Merchant |
|---|
